Biz-novosti

Justices make it easier for companies to defend patent cases


The Supreme Court on Monday unanimously ruled that patent infringement suits can only be filed in the judicial district where the alleged patent infringer is incorporated.

Apple, Google, Microsoft, Samsung and other heavyweight technology companies are often tangled in patent disputes, but this ruling is not for them specifically.

In 2016, 44 percent of all patent cases were filed in only two districts, the Eastern District of Texas and the District of DE, the district in which this case arose. In recent years, a single judge based in Marshall, Texas, oversaw about a quarter of all patent cases nationwide, more than the number handled by all federal judges in California, Florida and NY combined. The popularity of eastern Texas as a venue for patent lawsuits has created a cottage industry in cities like Tyler-an entire economic infrastructure has been developed to support the courts' adjudication of these lawsuits, perhaps further reinforcing the plaintiff-friendly culture in those communities. The main difference is that most cases would shift out of the Eastern District of Texas, but two other districts would see a potentially commensurate uptick in filings - the Northern District of California and the District of Delaware.

The U.S. Supreme Court issued a ruling Monday that may have effectively ended a 15-year intellectual property litigation boom in East Texas.

In an 8-0 decision, the Supreme Court answered in the negative and reversed the Federal Circuit. In fact, because any lawsuit will likely need to be filed in a venue in which the accused infringed has the advantage, patent trolls may find it more hard to extort settlements from their victims.

Davis homers twice in extra innings, Orioles edge Tigers
Danny Duffy picked up first victory since April 14, and Mike Moustakas belted a three-run homer as Kansas City defeated NY . Wood (4-0, 2.27) has been overpowering of late, striking out 21 over 11 scoreless innings in his past two starts.

"Today's opinion from the Supreme Court is an important step in restoring balance in litigation and confidence in the patent system", said the Business Software Alliance, a Washington, D.C. -based trade association.

Dickinson said a wave of lawsuits against retailers could prompt Congress to enact legislation shielding them from patent lawsuits relating to products they do not manufacture. Thomas wrote that because of this interpretation, updates to the rules by Congress did not change a 1957 Supreme Court decision that had previously found that patent suits must take place in the targeted company's home state.

In 2014, Kraft, a DE company, brought a patent infringement action in the district of DE against an in company, TC Heartland. The case was between food and beverage company Kraft Heinz Co. and beverage flavoring firm TC Heartland LLC. That Washington-based patent court ruled past year that patent lawsuits can be held anywhere a defendant's products are sold. Wherever there is money to be made there will always be opportunistic individuals and companies who will obtain patents in order to profit from licensing or litigation. Even Texas Solicitor General Scott Keller led a coalition of 17 states calling for an end to so-called "forum shopping" in patent cases. "Forum-shopping in patent cases will largely become a relic of history", he said.

The court's newest member, Justice Neil Gorsuch, did not participate in the consideration of the case or the court's decision. "In contrast, the federal District Court for the District of DE will undoubtedly see a significant rise in patent litigation, owing to the large number of corporations incorporated in DE".

Related Articles

  • Rebel Wilson's defamation trial against publisher begins

    Rebel Wilson's defamation trial against publisher begins

    Her immediate family and actor Hugh Sheridan are all expected to give evidence during the three week trial. Ms Wilson is suing publisher Bauer Media over eight articles published by its magazines in 2015.
    China cripples CIA operations, kills informants

    China cripples CIA operations, kills informants

    An FBI employee pleaded guilty to relaying sensitive technology information to Beijing for money and prostitutes past year . This set off alarm bells in the USA , prompting the CIA and the Federal Investigation Agency to begin an investigation.
    Skipping your beauty sleep may make you lose friends!

    Skipping your beauty sleep may make you lose friends!

    The volunteers were perceived to be less healthy-looking, less sociable and less intelligent after half the amount of sleep. Because we've evolved to try to avoid diseases, seeing an unhealthy-looking face makes us want to avoid that person.
  • Haitians who came after natural disaster  granted six-month extension

    Haitians who came after natural disaster granted six-month extension

    USA officials, though, said in their conversations they believe the Haitian government wants its people back at some point. In the leaked memo, McCament recommended extending the program for six months, out of a possible 18.
    Despite warnings on Flynn, Trump dismisses Russian collusion

    Despite warnings on Flynn, Trump dismisses Russian collusion

    Spicer later denied that Yates showed serious worry about Flynn's call, and said she simply gave "a heads up" about it. Republicans have seized on that statement as vindication for the Trump campaign, but investigations are ongoing.
    Planned Parenthood to close 4 Iowa clinics after funding cut

    Planned Parenthood to close 4 Iowa clinics after funding cut

    Over 14,000 patients who trust PP with their care will no longer have access to their provider of choice. By law, federal funds can not be used to pay directly for abortions except in narrow circumstances.
  • High court's good call on districts

    High court's good call on districts

    As of this writing, the most newsworthy of the lot is the case about how congressional district lines are drawn in North Carolina. The Supreme Court in 2013 struck down a key part of the Voting Rights Act in a ruling driven by its conservative justices .

    Syria war: United States coalition strikes pro-Assad militia near Jordan

    In a statement, the US -led coalition said it had struck "pro-regime forces. that posed a threat to USA and partner forces". This was the third attack by American forces against Assad's military in recent months, The New York Times reported .
    National Hockey League  playoffs: Ducks pull even with Predators

    National Hockey League playoffs: Ducks pull even with Predators

    For the past couple of years, it's held true: nothing's more fierce than a pissed-off Penguin (note: not true in nature). Rinne made a save on a Jakob Silfverberg's backhand attempt in the third period with his right pad to keep the game 2-0.
  • Mauricio Pochettino hints at

    Mauricio Pochettino hints at "creative" Spurs formation change vs Leicester

    It took his tally to 26 for the season - despite missing nearly three months of the season through injury! Kane has 32 goals in 37 appearances in all competitions and 26 in only 29 Premier League outings.
    Source says Lonzo Ball uncertain on non-Lakers workouts

    Source says Lonzo Ball uncertain on non-Lakers workouts

    The Celtics had a 25 percent chance to get the top pick, thanks to Brooklyn finishing with the worst record in the league. Pierce, who retired at the end of the season, took to Twitter to acknowledge his hand in the Celtics' lottery fortune.
    Real ID Bill Passes Minn. House and Senate, Heads to Gov. Dayton

    Real ID Bill Passes Minn. House and Senate, Heads to Gov. Dayton

    Budget negotiations resumed Friday, May 19, but leaders were tight-lipped about their first closed-door meeting in two days. That plan still led to a messy, one-day special session that almost derailed over disagreements on environmental spending.

Comments