Judge Orders Charges Brought Against Amtrak Engineer, Reversing Prosecutors' Decision

Judge Marsha Neifield of Philadelphia Municipal Court issued an order saying Brandon Bostian could be charged with involuntary manslaughter and reckless endangerment.

Attorney Thomas Kline, who had sought the private complaint on the Jacobs family's behalf, said the charges wouldn't have happened "had a courageous family, the Jacobs family, not stood up against the decision of a local prosecutor not to press charges".

After Neifield's order, Cameron L. Kline, communications director for the district attorney's office, said in a statement: "Judge Neifield has ordered the filing of two private criminal complaints as a result of the Amtrak train 188 derailment".

The judge ruled that charges of involuntary manslaughter and reckless endangerment can be brought against Bostian, both as misdemeanors.

Earlier this week the Philadelphia district attorney said while it was clear the derailment was caused by speeding, there was not enough clear evidence to file criminal charges.

Philadelphia prosecutors released a statement Thursday indicating that they will refer Bostian's prosecution to the state's attorney general to avoid a conflict of interest.

In addition to the eight people killed, more than 200 people were injured in the crash.

Investigators with the National Transportation Safety Board said Bostian accelerated to full-throttle as the New York-bound train traversed a straightaway through North Philadelphia.

Brewers 11, Red Sox 7
LHP Eduardo Rodriguez (1-1) has been respectable on the road to begin the season, going 1-1 with a 3.71 ERA in three starts. The Boston Red Sox permanently banned a fan from Fenway Park after his use of a racial slur towards another fan.

Amtrak has accepted responsibility for the crash and agreed to pay $265 million to settle related claims.

However, the NTSB concluded that nothing struck his locomotive and victims' lawyers had questioned why Bostian would have sped up, rather than slow down, if he had been startled by something striking the train.

The district attorney says there was no evidence Bostian acted with criminal "intent" or criminal "knowledge". He said he was left disoriented or unconscious when something struck his train before it derailed. However, federal safety investigators concluded that nothing struck the train prior to it crashing.

That, according to lawyer Robert Mongeluzzi who also represents victims, should not give him a pass.

Court records list addresses for Bostian in New York City and in Somerville, Massachusetts, near Boston.

"The private complaint mechanism exists for cases where the police can't make an arrest and, arguably, for cases where they won't but they should", Epstein said.

"Can you imagine someone driving down Market Street", Sprague said, "at 100 miles per hour, hitting people, killing people, and the DA saying, "We don't have a basis for prosecuting anybody"?"

The second-degree felony charge that Brandon Bostian faces carries a punishment of up to 10 years in prison. They found no evidence he was under the influence of drugs or alcohol or distracted by a cellphone.

Related Articles

  • Meet the next Windows 10

    Expect to see this feature show up in a Windows 10 Insider build this summer with general availability this fall. A user's Windows experience will move from device to device, using Microsoft's mobile apps for Android and iOS.
    Police from three states hunt for Justice Karnan

    Police from three states hunt for Justice Karnan

    Advocate Mathews J Nedumpara, who mentioned the plea before the apex court bench, was asked by J S Khehar about his whereabouts. Calcutta High Court judge Justice C S Karnan on Thursday sought relief from the Supreme Court in the contempt of court matter.
    Israeli authorities release fabricated video to try to undermine Palestinian hunger strike

    Israeli authorities release fabricated video to try to undermine Palestinian hunger strike

    He said that "the prisoners will not buy this account from the Israeli side, and they will continue their strike". Hundreds of Palestinian prisoners in Israeli jails are now on hunger strike over their conditions.
  • Penguins' Hagelin a game-time decision for Game 2 vs. Caps

    Maple Leafs fans will remember that it was in Ottawa where Auston Matthews made his spectacular National Hockey League debut. With Game 2 in Washington on Saturday night, Bonino knows it will be hard to take a 2-0 series lead with the same showing.
    Pakistan, Afghanistan dispute toll after clashes

    Pakistan, Afghanistan dispute toll after clashes

    The Pakistan DGMO asked his Afghan counterpart to direct his troops to defuse the situation, Dawn news reported. Both countries accuse each other of providing jihadists with safe zones to launch attacks across the border.
    Tyson: 'It's all about Joshua now - that one fight changed boxing'

    Tyson: 'It's all about Joshua now - that one fight changed boxing'

    In the 11th, Joshua unloaded a bone-jarring right uppercut that almost severed Klitschko's head from his neck. That is what makes boxing big, it is the heavyweights.
  • Indian shares extend record-breaking run; autos, banks rally

    FIIs bought shares worth net Rs332.87 crore on Tuesday, as per provisional figures issued by stock exchanges. Zee Entertainment Enterprises jumped 5.7% to 545.35 rupees, taking its two-day gains to almost 10%.
    Newcastle win Championship, Blackburn relegated on dramatic final day

    Newcastle win Championship, Blackburn relegated on dramatic final day

    Blackburn had lifted themselves out of the drop zone earlier in the day thanks to Mulgrew's superb free-kick into the top corner. Britt Assombalonga scored twice and missed a penalty as two-time European champions Forest survived on goal difference.

    Diego Simeone reacts in aftermath of Real Madrid embarrassment

    It was bad when Dani Carvajal went down injured against Atletico Madrid , but it's gotten even worse for the Merengues. It was a match filled with emotion, the team was phenomenal and scoring three goals made it a special night", he said.
  • Frat member told 911: 'We have a friend who's unconscious'

    Frat member told 911: 'We have a friend who's unconscious'

    As ABC News reported Friday, all defendants charged with involuntary manslaughter were preliminarily arraigned Friday afternoon. Piazza's father, Jim Piazza, said at a press conference Friday morning, "This didn't have to happen".

    IPL-10: Punjab eye desperate win against Gujarat

    His 5th boundary of the innings, which came off Basil Thampi's bowling in the 17th over, was a subject of discussion. His partnership of 125 with Marsh set the tone for a brisk finish, which included 66 runs off the last five overs.
    If anyone can resolve Kashmir problem, it is PM Modi, says Mehbooba

    If anyone can resolve Kashmir problem, it is PM Modi, says Mehbooba

    Chief Minister Mehbooba Mufti on Saturday reiterated her stand of initiating the dialogue process to restore peace in Kashmir. Mehbooba was addressing a gathering after inaugurating a flyover here.